Today I had the pleasure of attending the Children’s Literature Council of Southern California’s Fall Gala. It’s an event my friends and I look forward to each year because we always come away with a deep-down-good feeling as well as renewed enthusiasm for books in general and children’s lit in particular.
The morning was not unlike so many of the Fall Gala’s that I’ve attended in previous years. There were
plenty of fun moments – such as when Jennifer Holm ( BabyMouse ) pulled out her cell phone and called her brother Matt from the podium – just so that he could talk to one of his favorite artists, Berkley Breathed (Pete & Pickles).
And other moments when we were moved to tears – as when one of the
presenters shared the impact, on her personally, of Hope Anita Smith’s award winning book, Keeping the Night Watch.
As wonderful as these moments were, however, the most poignant, for me, came when the Dorothy C. McKenzie Award winner was announced. Not because the winner, Joanne Spring, is someone I know. Nor because I was already familiar with the literacy project, Monrovia Reads, that she helped spearhead in one of our local cities. But because it seemed to me to be exactly what I, as an educator, book-lover, and writer, hope to encourage both professionally and privately: Reading Changes Everything.
Joanne’s enthusiasm for her community’s literacy project and the strategies the city has employed to support and encourage reading are in direct contrast to a troubling letter a friend shared with me the other day regarding the way a local Southern California school district (Burbank Unified *) has chosen to encourage reading.
Can you guess? AR – Accelerated Reader. What’s most troubling is that the superintendent has shared a disturbing and poorly written letter with the school district’s K- 12 families encouraging them to support independent reading in their community by paying $10 to enroll in the AR program.
Can you imagine? And it gets worse! There are prizes. Not of the small, trinket variety. Instead, the prizes are limo rides to special meals and/or tours in the community, board presentations of awards that will be aired on local t.v. and streamed on the internet. And … a CAR!! Valued at over $14,500 (!). It brings to mind a t.v. show from my childhood – “Let’s Make A Deal!”
Is this really how a school district wants to emphasize the importance of reading? I think not. All I can say is that I’m glad I don’t work for Burbank Unified, and while I am sure that plenty of school districts and teachers appropriately use programs such as Accelerated Reader to encourage reading, the misdirected focus of Burbank Unified is disturbing.
* follow the link and click on: “Current Events: How to Win a Car”
Jim Trelease, author of The Read-Aloud Handbook, has written about Accelerated Reader and offers up his thoughts here. In a nutshell, it seems Trelease believes AR can be successfully used as one of the ways students are encouraged to read. But implementation and understanding of the whys and hows of the program are key.
Sadly, when I read the letter from the office of Burbank Unified’s superintendent, I didn’t get the feeling the district was addressing the issue of improved independent reading levels because of a balanced understanding of the research. I can only hope that I have entirely misunderstood the superintendant’s intent and that there are many teachers in Burbank’s district who will take it upon themselves to provide a balanced reading program in their own classrooms.
Admittedly, since we don’t have AR at my school, my experience is skewed. I would love to hear what others think of AR. Does it work? How does *your* school keep the goal of encouraging independent reading in balance?
In a future post, I’ll share what *I* do to encourage independent reading in my own classroom. But here’s
a quick peek: I bought more BabyMouse books so that the students in my classroom don’t have to wait as long to read what has become one of our classroom’s favorite series. And I go to events such as today’s CLC Fall Gala, so that I
can share a few fun facts about the authors I’ve met. And if I’m able, I get a few pictures, as I did today, because my students will be thrilled to know I really *did* meet one of their favorite authors!